Square vs PayPal: Key Differences Every Merchant Should Know

In the fast-paced realm of ecommerce, selecting the right payment processing solution is vital for success. Square and PayPal are two top contenders, providing a variety of services designed for online businesses.

Square, founded in 2009 by Jack Dorsey and Jim McKelvey, revolutionized mobile payments with its intuitive card reader and has since expanded into a comprehensive financial ecosystem.

PayPal, established in 1998 and gaining widespread popularity through its association with eBay, stands as one of the most recognized and trusted online payment platforms globally.

For ecommerce businesses, understanding how Square vs PayPal compare in terms of features, pricing, support, and integration capabilities is essential. This article provides an in-depth analysis to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your business needs.

Feature Overview of PayPal vs Square

Here are the main features of Square and Paypal lined compiled in a table:

‍

In-Depth Feature Analysis

In this section we have created an in-depth head-to-head on Square and PayPal, focusing on the most crucial features.

Payment Processing Fees

Transaction costs significantly impact an ecommerce business's profitability. Square charges a flat rate of 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction and 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person transactions, with no monthly fees for basic services. PayPal also charges 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction but adds an extra 1.5% fee for international sales, plus potential currency conversion fees.

• Domestic Transactions: Both platforms offer similar rates, making them equally suitable for businesses focusing on domestic sales.
• International Sales: PayPal's additional fees for cross-border transactions can increase costs, whereas Square's limited international support may restrict global expansion.

If Square is the one for you, make sure you check out these other 9 Square alternatives.

Point-of-Sale (POS) Hardware

For ecommerce businesses looking to expand into physical retail or pop-up shops, reliable POS hardware is essential. Square offers a variety of proprietary hardware, including the Square Reader, Square Stand, and Square Register, catering to different business needs. In contrast, PayPal is limited to the PayPal Here Card Reader and relies on third-party providers for advanced POS features.

• Square's Advantage: The range of hardware options makes it a better choice for omnichannel ecommerce businesses.
• PayPal's Limitation: Reliance on third-party hardware may complicate setup and incur extra costs.

Ecommerce Integration

Seamless integration with ecommerce platforms is vital for operational efficiency and customer experience. Square provides the Square Online Store, a free website builder powered by Weebly, and integrates with platforms like WooCommerce, Wix, and Magento. PayPal, on the other hand, natively integrates with major platforms such as Shopify, WooCommerce, and Magento, and offers APIs for custom websites.

• PayPal's Strength: Broader compatibility and payment options may enhance the shopping experience and reduce cart abandonment.
• Square's Suitability: Ideal for businesses seeking an all-in-one solution without extensive customization.

Mobile Payment Support

With the rise of mobile shopping, supporting mobile payments is crucial for ecommerce success. Square accepts Apple Pay, Google Pay, and other contactless payments, and its Square POS App allows merchants to manage sales, inventory, and customer interactions on mobile devices. PayPal supports payments via the PayPal App and PayPal One Touch, enabling quick checkouts, and also accepts Apple Pay for in-app and web payments.

• PayPal's Appeal: Widespread consumer adoption may attract more customers, potentially increasing mobile sales.
• Square's Flexibility: Robust mobile app benefits merchants needing flexible, on-the-go transaction capabilities.

Invoicing Features

Efficient invoicing aids in cash flow management, which is essential for ecommerce businesses dealing with varying order volumes. Square provides free invoicing with customizable templates, including features like recurring payments and automated reminders. PayPal also offers invoicing capabilities with customizable templates, but advanced features like recurring billing may incur additional fees.

• Square's Cost-Effectiveness: Comprehensive invoicing features at no additional cost make it ideal for small to medium-sized businesses.
• PayPal's Advanced Options: May be better for businesses requiring advanced billing options despite potential extra fees.

Security Measures

Security is paramount in ecommerce to protect both the business and customers. Square is PCI compliant with end-to-end encryption and fraud detection tools. PayPal offers industry-leading security with PCI compliance, Seller Protection for eligible transactions, and advanced fraud detection systems.

• Robust Security: Both platforms provide strong security measures to protect transactions.
• PayPal's Seller Protection: Particularly beneficial for merchants concerned about chargebacks and fraudulent transactions.

Pricing Models

Understanding the overall cost structure helps in financial planning and profitability analysis.

Square Pricing

• Transaction Fees: 2.9% + $0.30 online; 2.6% + $0.10 in-person.
• Hardware Costs: Ranging from $49 for the Square Reader to $799 for the Square Register.
• Software Fees: Basic features are free; premium services like Square Marketing start at $15/month.
• Additional Services: Instant transfers available at a 1.5% fee per transaction amount.

PayPal Pricing

• Transaction Fees: 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction; additional 1.5% for international sales.
• Hardware Costs: $24.99 for the PayPal Here Card Reader.
• Software Fees: No monthly fees for basic services; PayPal Payments Pro costs $30/month for advanced features.
• Additional Services: Instant transfers to bank accounts at a 1% fee per transaction (up to $10 max).
• Consideration: Square may require a higher upfront investment due to hardware purchases but offers more comprehensive solutions for omnichannel ecommerce operations. PayPal's international fees can increase costs for businesses with significant global sales.

Pick the Right Solution for Your Ecommerce Business

Choosing between Square and PayPal depends on your ecommerce business's specific needs and strategic goals.

Choose Square if:

• You need an integrated POS system with various hardware options for both online and offline sales.
• Your business operates primarily within supported countries (U.S., Canada, U.K., Australia, Japan).
• You value an all-in-one solution with straightforward pricing and no monthly fees for basic services.
• Ecommerce-specific needs include seamless inventory management across online and physical stores.

Choose PayPal if:

• International sales are significant for your business, requiring support in over 200 countries and 25 currencies.
• Offering customers multiple payment options, including PayPal Credit and Venmo, is a priority.
• Brand recognition and customer trust are crucial for your strategy, potentially reducing cart abandonment.
• You require advanced customization for your online checkout experience, enhancing customer engagement.

By evaluating these factors, you can select the payment solution that best aligns with your operational needs and growth objectives. Consider testing both platforms to determine which offers the most value for your ecommerce enterprise.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Here we answer some common questions about using Square and PayPal for your ecommerce business, helping you make an informed decision.

Can I use both Square and PayPal on my ecommerce site?

Yes, integrating both allows customers to choose their preferred payment method, potentially increasing conversion rates and customer satisfaction.

Which platform is better for international sales?

PayPal supports more countries and currencies, making it more suitable for global ecommerce despite higher international fees. Square's limited international support may restrict businesses aiming for worldwide markets.

Do Square and PayPal offer protection against fraud?

Both platforms provide robust security measures, including fraud detection tools and PCI compliance. PayPal offers Seller Protection for eligible transactions, covering chargebacks for unauthorized transactions and items not received.

How quickly can I access my funds?

Square typically deposits funds into your bank account within 1-2 business days, with instant transfers available for a 1.5% fee per transaction amount. PayPal makes funds available immediately in your PayPal account, with standard bank transfers taking 1-3 business days and instant transfers available for a 1% fee per transaction (up to $10 max).

Can I process recurring payments with Square and PayPal?

Yes, both platforms support recurring billing. Square offers this feature for free, which is beneficial for subscription-based ecommerce businesses. PayPal may charge additional fees for advanced subscription services.

Are there any monthly fees associated with Square or PayPal?

Square has no monthly fees for basic services, though premium features like Square Marketing or Payroll have additional costs. PayPal's basic services also have no monthly fees, but PayPal Payments Pro, which offers advanced features like a virtual terminal, costs $30/month.

Do they support integration with ecommerce platforms like Shopify or WooCommerce?

Square integrates with platforms like WooCommerce, Wix, and Magento, but does not natively integrate with Shopify. PayPal seamlessly integrates with major platforms including Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento, and BigCommerce.

What customer support options are available?

Square offers phone support during business hours, extensive online resources, and community forums. PayPal provides 24/7 customer support via phone and email, plus a comprehensive help center and community forum.

‍